Ask your tax adviser to identify the exact valuation breakdown before ordering. When a main house and an accessory dwelling unit share a property, but only one is rented, a single whole-property value may leave an important question unanswered. Clarify whether the recipient needs total value, an allocation between specified residential components, a land-and-improvement breakdown, or more than one of those conclusions.
The overlooked distinction is between allocating expenses and allocating value. A percentage used for shared utility bills does not automatically establish the rental dwelling’s share of the property’s market value.
Tell the appraiser which dwelling or area is rented and what comes with it. Identify exclusive and shared parking, storage, yard, access and utility arrangements. Explain the use of the other dwelling: personal occupancy, vacancy, another tenancy or a proposed change. “The property is a rental” can hide these differences.
Provide plans, available area measurements, permits and the relevant lease terms. A detached building, separate entrance or mailing address should not be treated as proof that a dwelling can be sold independently. If separate sale is part of your question, disclose that proposed scenario and obtain the applicable title and land-use advice.
For uncertainty about the physical space or records, see Alpha’s ADU and addition appraisal guide. This article does not determine rental legality or permit eligibility.
Ask the adviser to put the requested output in writing. These questions should not be compressed into one instruction to “value the rental”:
A component’s contribution to one property is a different question from what it might sell for as an independent property. Ask the report to explain which question was analyzed. If the requested components are meant to reconcile to a whole-property total, say so; do not silently combine figures developed under different premises.
IRS Publication 527 discusses dividing shared rental and personal expenses using a reasonable method, including room-count or area methods in its guidance. That discussion concerns expenses. It is not an instruction to multiply a whole-property appraisal by the same percentage and call the result an independently appraised component value.
For valuation work, describe differences in condition, utility, privacy, access and shared facilities rather than choosing a preferred percentage first. Give the appraiser any allocation already used, explain its purpose and identify its source. The appraiser can then assess what evidence and analysis the requested opinion needs. A measurement can document area without settling the value allocation.
Record acquisition, construction or renovation completion, availability for rent, lease commencement and changes in occupancy separately. The main dwelling and ADU may not have followed the same timeline.
Publication 527 describes placement in service in terms of being ready and available for the specified rental use. The first tenant’s move-in date therefore should not be selected automatically as the valuation date. Have the tax adviser identify the applicable date and explain the requested appraisal evidence. For an earlier date, use retrospective valuation guidance and supply records showing what existed then.
IRS Publication 551 separately addresses adjusted basis and property changed from personal to rental use, including the comparison of adjusted basis and fair market value for depreciation. An appraisal supplies agreed valuation evidence; the tax adviser determines the applicable basis, adjustments and tax calculations. A higher appraised value does not by itself establish a higher depreciation basis.
If the adviser also needs a market-rent conclusion, request it explicitly; see what to order for a market-rent opinion. Do not divide value according to the rent collected from only one dwelling. Disclose the actual lease and ask which property interest the value opinion should address. The tenant-occupied appraisal guide explains the occupancy question.
A residential allocation is not a cost-segregation study or tax-return preparation. It also does not decide equity, legal entitlement, ownership percentages or agreed buyout terms. If an existing report lacks the requested breakdown, send the complete report and written request to its appraiser before ordering again. Additional analysis is not automatically a clerical correction.
For a home in King County, Snohomish County or Skagit County, request a residential appraisal quote. Include your name, email and phone number, property address, purpose, intended users, requested dates and deadline. Describe each dwelling’s use, the shared areas, available historical records and the adviser’s requested allocation. Arrange document delivery before sending confidential tax or tenant information.
Qualifying residential appraisals start at $695. A complex property or additional allocation work can require a different fee; Alpha will discuss fit, scope, fee and availability before scheduling. A quote request is not a booking or a promise that a particular tax-related scope can be accepted.
Call 425-753-1971 or email dustin.labrasseur@gmail.com. Office hours are Monday through Friday, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Pacific. Dustin LaBrasseur is a Washington Certified Residential Real Estate Appraiser, credential 1703357, with 12+ years of experience.
Written November 21, 2026. Primary sources checked November 21, 2026: